From The Blog
Mar 16th
Are You a Good Enough Manager?
posted by Jules and has 3 awesome commentsDelivering one to one management training, you would think, would be a fairly straightforward activity once to you are practiced and expert at what you do. However, I found myself in a very unusual situation with client last week that really took me by surprise.
The previous week I had spent two days with this client and their team delivering my team building event called Moments of Clarity. Two days with the same group of people giving them the time and space to explore all of their team issues gives me the chance to really understand what makes them tick, how they work together and what their main issues are.
In my experience, the manager is usually at fault for many of the issues teams suffer. Lack of consistency in the application of the ‘rules of operation’, failing to share the vision and avoiding dealing with conflict situations for fear of further disruption or not being liked are all fairly common. In many ways this team were no different, so when I was preparing for the first one to one session with the manager I felt confident that I had a good idea of how the session was going to shape up.
Cripes was I wrong. I always use a basic questionnaire as a starting point, part of which asks the client to rate themselves out of 10 in various management disciplines and this always gives me a place to start. As I adopt a fairly loose and intuitive style with clients I will often find we’ve gone off down a path that I hadn’t planned for but we always end up in the right place, talking about and resolving the issues that really matter.
The beginning of the session was fine and progressed as I expected. However, after a while I began to notice that as I was explaining ways of tackling certain management situations my client kept nodding and saying “yes, I already do that”. My client had rated themselves as 5 out of 10 in many of the typical management disciplines such as ‘Conducting Effective Meetings’, ‘Time Management’, ‘Motivating Staff’, etc etc which I could see this was completely at odds with their experience and knowledge.
Further exploration uncovered that this client is actually a very skilled manager, possessing the right skills, knowledge and attitude to take their team forward successfully. What we uncovered was that they didn’t feel like a good manager. At first I didn’t quite know what to do but after a little more conversation I realised that this client didn’t need my help. They just needed to understand and accept that they were actually a good enough manager.
This lack of understanding and acceptance was rooted in personal issues that I am not qualified to assist with. So we came to an agreement that my client would use the next session already booked with me to do some work with another professional that I work with occasionally who I know would be much better placed to help with the issues we talked about.
Reflecting a few days later I know I have made the right recommendations but it has thrown up some thoughts for me that I would like to share with those managers out there who feel that they could do better.
Please check your knowledge and skill levels by researching management skills on the internet, reading the latest management technique books or revisiting materials from previous training courses – not with the aim of learning something new but with the aim of comparing it against what you’re already doing. Be brutally honest with yourself – don’t use false modesty as a way of not bragging or being big headed. If you are doing all of the things that you should be doing, give yourself a tick in the box. Feel proud of what you’ve achieved to date and celebrate all of the good things that you do for your company and your team.
It’s the easiest thing in the world to talk yourself down because you are the one person you’ll believe – aren’t you?
Obviously, if you have never received any management training then getting some would probably help but don’t automatically assume that because you’ve never had any that you’re not a good manager.
If you are very brave you can always ask your team what they think of you by giving them a 360 degree anonymous feedback questionnaire to complete. It’s not for the fainthearted and if you’re interested get in touch and I can send you the questionnaire and talk you through it.
It often seems to me that we live in a culture of regularly pointing out the negative and worst in people. Our newspapers and TV are full of ‘not good enough’ messages from not pretty enough, not thin enough, not skilled enough, not nice enough – the list is endless. So much so that it’s easy to see why many of us think we might not be good enough managers. My client is a good manager and if you are having doubts about your skills and competency as a manager maybe you should give it a little more thought and give yourself a bit less of a hard time.
As always, I would love to know what you think and more particularly, whether this has struck a chord with you and whether you are actually good enough as a manager.
I look forward to hearing from you and if you need a bit of inspiration to help you along the way this always does it for me (If you don’t feel comfortable with the word ‘God’ feel free to replace it with ‘universe’ or ‘the world’ as you prefer – it still works):
“Our deepest fear is not that we are inadequate. Our deepest fear is that we are powerful beyond measure. It is our light, not our darkness that most frightens us. We ask ourselves, who am I to be brilliant, gorgeous, talented, fabulous? Actually, who are you not to be? You are a child of God. Your playing small does not serve the world. There is nothing enlightened about shrinking so that other people won’t feel insecure around you. We are all meant to shine, as children do. We were born to make manifest the glory of God that is within us. It’s not just in some of us; it’s in everyone. And as we let our own light shine, we unconsciously give other people permission to do the same. As we are liberated from our own fear, our presence automatically liberates others.”
This inspiring quote by Marianne Williamson is from her book, A Return To Love: Reflections on the Principles of A Course in Miracles, Harper Collins, 1992. From Chapter 7, Section 3 (Pg. 190-191).
© 2009 U Turn TV | This site was cleverly put together by
Comments
sarah
March 19th 2010 5:37pmi Think it can be difficult as sometimes managers can be in an unsupported role and could find it difficult to keep a realisitic view of things. I think especially if dealing with a lot of negativity within a team it can be difficult to step back and see the positives without someone else pointing them out.
I feel it is a very important factor that managers actually have a supportive mentor/team leader whatever and have regular supervision sessions themselves that will help to keep them “on track” and be able to discuss things and how they were dealt with.
It is a whole lot more difficult if the manager is left to do this for themselves with no backup
after all-we all just want someone to say “well done!” or even “thank you”
Jules
March 22nd 2010 5:18pmDear Sarah
Thank you for taking the time to leave your comments.
One of the things I have noticed with a number of my clients is that they have been ‘left to get on with’ the management role. Even though there is a manager in the technical sense, it seems common to have the senior person above you to be remote or almost entirely absent. This leaves managers, as you say, feeling unsupported and out on a limb.
The outcomes from this ‘absense of management’ are many and varied but one common theme is the one you mention of not having someone around to say ‘well done’ or ‘thank you’. I know from my clients and my own experience that it takes very little to keep managers motivated and on track – and it’s certainly not always money at the top of the list either!
More than once when training a manager I have had to operate as their manager for the duration of a piece of work to help them understand how they should be performing.
This has actually made me realise that clients might want a new service offering from me where I am retained on a permanent basis to be available to them on a regular basis. So in a round about sort of way Sarah, thank you for helping me decide on a new service offering.
The one good thing about your experiences are that when you progress to the next level in your career and start managing managers you will know what it takes to keep them motivated.
Again, I genuinely appreciate that you’ve taken the time to comment on my blog. Thank you so much.
Lots of love
Jules
x
sarah
March 22nd 2010 7:54pmThat is an absolutely brilliant idea!! I think especially when it comes to the voluntary sector where a management committee consists of people who may be dedicated to the cause but do not have the knowledge or skills to fully understand the manager’s role and be able to support in an appropriate manner.
It would be brilliant to “buy in” that vital support and it would be totally non biased view from your side-even when managers are supported it can sometimes be difficult as all parties are “involved” and emotions can run high.
yes, that is a brilliant idea Jules
xx